Insurance in the COVID-19 Era, Can Insurance Save Your Business? By Miriam Tepperman Blog, COVID-19, Insurance DefenceMay 12, 2020September 30, 2020 This is a time of great uncertainty where businesses are incurring losses and extra expenses due to the coronavirus. The question is: who has to bear these losses? Is it the businesses themselves? Government? Insurance? Your company may have insurance that can help save your business during these unprecedented times. This article does not constitute legal advice What Insurance Does the Business Have? Property/Business Interruption Act of God/Force Majeuere Commercial General Liability Policy Umbrella or Excess Policies Civil Authority Extension All Risks Policy Environmental Insurance Policy Event Cancellation Policy Infectious Disease Endorsement Non-Physical Damage Endorsement Pandemic Endorsement A Policy With Specialized Wording What Is Business Interruption Coverage? Business interruption insurance is intended to indemnify a business for its loss of profit and additional expenses that arise due to an insured peril.[[i]] What Is “Act Of God” Coverage? “Act of God” or “Force Majeure” in insurance terms is a damaging event that is beyond human control, for example, an earthquake or a hurricane[[ii]]; however most policies have specific exclusions for natural disasters and viruses under the excluded perils exclusions in its policies. Does the Commercial General Liability Policy Provide the Necessary Coverage? Many Commercial General Liability Policies provide business interruption insurance but unfortunately, many businesses only have such coverage under their commercial property insurance policy.[[iii]] If that is the case, business interruption arising out of property damage may trigger the policy but an event such as coronavirus is unlikely to do so if the claim is for lost income due to loss demand in this coronavirus era. That said, if the business is unable to operate due to the presence of the contagion in the premises, then more questions should be asked.[[iv]] For example, if a manufacturer of food has to shut down while the facilities are disinfected, it becomes a more interesting question, than whether the facilities are losing revenue because the demand for its product has fallen. Another thing to consider is whether there was “Act of God” coverage under the commercial general liability possibility.[[v]] Umbrella and/or Excess Policies These policies should be reviewed to consider whether they could be triggered. Infectious Disease Endorsement A business should determine if it has an infectious disease endorsement that may provide coverage for losses by infectious or communicable diseases. This may provide COVID-19 coverage for losses.[[vi]] Non-Physical Damage Endorsement Similarly, a business should consider if it has a non-physical damage endorsement as it may provide coverage for COVID-19 losses.[[vii]] Civil Authority Endorsement Civil authority endorsements relate to situations where access to the premises is prohibited by civil authority. Often the length of time may be specified such as 2-4 weeks.[[viii]] Issues will need to be considered about mandatory versus voluntary closures and whether there is a partial versus a complete closure and whether there was COVID-19 present versus a closure to prevent its presence. All Risks Policy The wording of the policy will need to be considered. This may be an area where COVID-19 claims may be covered through an argument that COVID-19 presents an identifiable risk to human health and safety. Litigation will likely be needed to determine if a virus is a “direct physical loss” under an All Risks policy. Environmental Insurance Policy Another policy that should be considered is an environmental loss policy. An environmental policy may cover losses from coronavirus if it covers biological contaminants and/or viruses and/or communicable diseases. It would need to cover indoor loss exposure. Many will not meet these criteria but they should be considered.[[ix]] Event Cancellation Policy Many events such as trade shows, festivals, sporting events, conferences, theatre and concerts may have event non-appearance or cancellation coverage. This provides insurance protection in cases where the headliner cannot appear for reasons such as illness or an accident. Many events have been cancelled due to the need for social distancing, so the non-appearance and cancellation clauses may be triggered.[[x]] Policies issued after January 23, 2020, may have a COVID-19 exclusion but policies obtained before that probably do not. Coverage can help the organizers recoup some expenses and losses. Pandemic Endorsement This is not a typical endorsement that a small or middle sized business is likely to have. This policy has been successfully triggered by Wimbledon and NCAA.[[xi]] Policy With Specialized Wording If your business is insured by a policy with specialized wording then there may be coverage where typically there may not be. Consideration of the wording is needed. Does Your Business Have Insurance Coverage Once the policies are identified and the particular endorsements and exclusions are identified, one needs to give consideration to the specific wording. At this point, it is unclear how insurers will consider coronavirus claims and whether they will be considered a “force majeure” or whether they will be excluded. There are currently no pending cases or judicial decisions on the issue, but that will undoubtedly change in the coming months. If you submit a claim and are denied, a legal opinion should be considered to determine whether you may have a viable claim or whether to take no as an answer. [i] Gord McGuire & Tim Zimmerman, “Are Coronavirus Losses Covered Under Business Interruption Insurance Policies?”, The Star (March 27, 2020), online: <https://www.thestar.com/opinion/2020/03/27/are-coronavirus-losses-covered-under-business-interruption-insurance-policies.html>. [ii] HUB Insights, “Act of God Insurance Claims Currently Remain Under Question as Businesses Look for Ways to Recoup Losses in the Wake of COVID-19”, HUB International (April 15, 2020), online: <https://www.hubinternational.com/blog/2020/04/act-of-god-insurance/>. [iii] Chetan Sehgal, Jay Ahluwalia, Matthew Law & Crawford Smith, “Insurance Coverage and COVID-19: Legal Considerations and Loss Quantification Developments”, BDO Canada (April 3, 2020), online: <https://www.bdo.ca/en-ca/insights/advisory/commercial-insurance-loss-accounting/insurance-coverage-considerations-on-covid-19/>. [iv] Gord McGuire & Tim Zimmerman, supra note 1. [v] HUB Insights, supra note 2. [vi] Tim Zimmerman & Gord McGuire, “The Calm Before the Storm: Business Interruption Insurance Litigation”, The Lawyer’s Daily (April 9, 2020), online: <https://www.thelawyersdaily.ca/articles/18561/the-calm-before-the-storm-business-interruption-insurance-litigation>. [vii] Ibid. [viii] Chetan Sehgal, Jay Ahluwalia, Matthew Law & Crawford Smith, supra note 4. [ix] David Dybdahl, “Environmental Insurance Coverage for COVID-19 and Other Biological Hazards”, IRMI (April 2020), online: <https://www.irmi.com/articles/expert-commentary/environmental-insurance-coverage-for-covid-19-losses>. [x] HUB Insights, “Coronavirus Resulting in Event Cancellation? Your Non-Appearance/Cancellation Policy May Help Counter Costs”, HUB International (April 10, 2020), online <https://www.hubinternational.com/en-CA/blog/2018/09/event-cancellation-insurance/>. [xi] HUB Insights, supra note 2. “Our articles are intended to inform. Its content does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon by readers as such. If you require legal assistance, please see a lawyer. Each case is unique and a lawyer with good training and sound judgment can provide you with advice tailored to your specific situation and needs.” Related Posts By Marty Rabinovitch and Kathrin Gardhouse Blog, COVID-19, Employment LawSeptember 15, 2020September 29, 2020 Temporary Layoffs During COVID-19 – “COVID-19 period” extended until January 2, 2021 On May 29, 2020, Ontario passed Regulation 228/20 under the Employment Standards Act (“ESA”). As a result of this new regulation, non-unionized workers who had their hours reduced or eliminated due to COVID-19 are deemed retroactively to be on Infectious Disease Emergency Leave, which is an unpaid, job-protected leave under the ESA. The regulation applies retroactively from March 1, 2020, and initially [...] Read more By Miriam Tepperman Blog, COVID-19, Insurance DefenceJune 15, 2020September 29, 2020 No comments yet An Open Email Dated June 15, 2020, From Insurance Defence Lawyer, Miriam Tepperman, To Our Attorney General Regarding the Importance of Jury Trials I am a proud insurance defence lawyer. I am proud of my role in the justice system that helps people get back on their feet after an injury while keeping the system honest. Both aspects are needed. The system is set up that for those that are injured and not so injured have to focus [...] Read more By Marc G. Spivak Blog, COVID-19, Personal InjuryJune 12, 2020September 29, 2020 An Open Email dated June 12, 2020, from Personal Injury Lawyer, Marc Spivak, to our Attorney General Regarding Suspending Juries in Civil Law Cases To the Honorable Doug Downey Attorney General of Ontario I am a personal injury lawyer and have been for 28 years. The first 9 years of my practice I acted for insurance companies on the defence of insurance matters. I can tell you firsthand the almost complete unfairness of the archaic jury system that we [...] Read more By Maya Krishnaratne Blog, COVID-19, ImmigrationJune 9, 2020September 29, 2020 No comments yet Reduced Travel Restrictions for Relatives of Canadians and PRs Recently, the government announced that “immediate family members” of Canadians and Canadian permanent residents will be exempt from the prohibition on entry to Canada if they are coming to be with their Canadian or PR family member for at least 15 days. This will hopefully serve to reduce the uncertainty many have faced since measures under the [...] Read more By Marty Rabinovitch Blog, COVID-19, Employment LawJune 2, 2020September 29, 2020 Amendments to the Employment Standards Act, 2000 – May 29, 2020 – Impact on Temporary Layoffs This blog is co-written by our former articling student, Janet Son. On May 29, 2020, Ontario passed Regulation 228/20 under the Employment Standards Act (“ESA”). During the pandemic, many businesses were forced to close and were faced with an impossible situation. According to the Financial Accountability Office of Ontario, approximately 2.2 million Ontario employees have experienced temporary layoffs, job losses [...] Read more
“Our articles are intended to inform. Its content does not constitute legal advice and should not be relied upon by readers as such. If you require legal assistance, please see a lawyer. Each case is unique and a lawyer with good training and sound judgment can provide you with advice tailored to your specific situation and needs.”